Step through Tony's humble red door into a cozy, family-run Italian gem where handcrafted pizzas, fresh pastas, and warm hospitality transport you straight to Italy—one delicious bite at a time.
Step through Tony's humble red door into a cozy, family-run Italian gem where handcrafted pizzas, fresh pastas, and warm hospitality transport you straight to Italy—one delicious bite at a time.
It earned 4.7★ across 973 reviews one plate at a time — fresh food, fair prices, and a welcome that keeps regulars coming back.
Come grab a seat and dig in. Simple, generous, and exactly what you came for.
Real photos from the restaurant. Tap to take a closer look.
Looking for something specific? Call and we'll sort it out →
4.7 · 973 Google reviews — earned one happy customer at a time.
Straightforward, fair prices with no surprises. What we quote is what you pay.
A simple, no-runaround process. Real people who get you taken care of fast.
Service that shows up — the kind your neighbors recommend by name.
"Excellent gluten free pizza options. 16" White pizza easily equals 2 meals. Restaurant is great for both small and large parties."
"Wonderful meal! Waitress was attentive even though they were very busy! Our appetizer came out quickly.. the calamari was the best I've had in a Vermont time! First time I've ever had garlic knots that were cheese stuffed.. did not disappoint 😋 Next time I'll ask for more garlic. All of us…"
"Driving through Starke we stopped at this local restaurant and we were very pleased. I had the Lasagna and it was very tasty. What would have made it better would have been if it was served hotter. My husband enjoyed the Ravioli Carbonara and said the sauce was very tasty. Their rolls were good.…"
Rated 4.7 out of 5 across 973 Google reviews.
We're in Starke, Union — easy to find, easy to work with. Give us a call and we'll take care of you.
or call +1 904-368-0032
Call Tony’s Italian Restaurant to reserve a table or ask about today's specials.